Holding Two Jewish Truths: Suffering and Justice

Jewish tradition teaches us that it is possible to hold two opposing truths in our hands, and in our hearts, at the same time. The practice most people think of that highlights this is when we break the glass during a Jewish wedding ceremony. In one of the happiest moments of someone’s life, they break a glass to remember the destruction of the synagogue in Jerusalem. It’s a reminder that at the height of personal joy, we recall the pain and losses suffered and remember a world in need of healing. And it is true that in the past year we have seen the very best of humanity and the very worst.  

It was on erev Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish New Year, that we learned about Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s death. That Justice Ginsburg died as the sun began to set marking that first night of our new year and High Holy Day is symbolic in our tradition. We’re told that the truly righteous, those we need the most, are left among us until the last minute of the year. Overwhelmed with grief, I felt compelled to go to the Supreme Court both to pay my respects to a personal hero and to mourn with others who I knew felt the same sense of loss. 

Moments after arriving, while standing on the steps of the Supreme Court, I heard the blasting sound of a shofar -the ram’s horn which is blown as a literal wake-up call to the Jewish people. It’s a signal that we need to act, to tell us to make amends for past misdeeds and recommit ourselves to a future that is better than the year we are leaving behind. A fitting message as we collectively took up the mantle of Justice Ginsburg’s legacy. 

At that moment, I was holding two truths, and am still holding them today. The truth is that people are suffering. The truth is also that people are standing up for justice. 

In less than a year, the coronavirus pandemic has cost more than 350,000 lives in our country alone: teachers, nurses, doctors, grocery store clerks, factory workers, long-haul drivers, mothers, fathers, siblings, cousins, beloved friends, and neighbors.  

At the same time, during this pandemic, and following the injustices of the murders of Breonna Taylor, George Floyd, Tony McDade, and Ahmaud Arbery, white Americans began the process of reckoning and reconciliation with our nation’s history of oppression and persecution, something that has been embedded into every facet of our society. Black activists, indigenous people, people of color, and those of all backgrounds, ages and identities have risen against the threats to Black lives and communities of color; neighbors are organizing to feed each other; Stacey Abrams and others who haven’t made as many headlines including Nse UfotLaTosha Brown, Helen Butler, Deborah Scott, and Tamieka Atkins are ensuring every American’s right to vote, and so many people of faith have turned their passion and beliefs into action.  

Both the suffering and the pursuit of justice stand true at the same time. We must hold and be responsive to both. 

We have the right to celebrate and take pride in the work that has been done, even as we acknowledge how much more there’s still to do.  

We have to continue the work of tikkun olam, repairing the world. It is the same work that was pursued by Justice Ginsburg, the work of Rep. John Lewis, of Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., the work of countless civil rights leaders, faith leaders, and pioneers who created the roadmap we must now follow. We have to fight, even if the odds are against us, and speak out for what is right. In the face of ongoing attempts to remove basic human rights and protections for the most vulnerable populations, including abortion access and affordable health care, it is on each and every one of us to continue making the world a better and more just place.  

As we enter into 2021 with a new presidential administration, National Council of Jewish Women believes we have the opportunity to create the America that so many who came before us believed could be a reality. An America that values civil rights, understands abortion as necessary health care, is committed to dismantling the systemic racism rooted in every facet of our nation, protects religious freedom, and prioritizes the most vulnerable.  

In the wake of a violent insurrection, this message and mission is all the more vital. Democracy is fragile and we must continue to protect it.  

We will do this by working together. It's the job of every citizen to continue to take action to build a better world. At NCJW we take that to heart, and we hold on to two truths at the same time: A better, more inclusive, more equitable nation is possible – and we still have a lot of work to do to achieve it. Please join us. 

Sheila Katz is the CEO of the National Council of Jewish Women. 


If you are looking for a way to become an interfaith leader, work for racial equity and build bridges, please check out our free curriculum "We Are Each Other's" and start your interfaith leadership today

more from IFYC

Raja writes about the usefulness or appropriateness of the term "BIPOC" - Black, Indigenous, People of Color- in discourse about race and justice, and how it relates to and reflects the politics of race and racism in the United States.
The river has been important since the dawn of civilization and has served as a commercial hub and lifeline for countless peoples over many millennia. Yet there has always seemed to be a justice that was out of reach for some.
"Many synagogues are leaning into the Purim tradition of giving gifts to friends and the poor— a custom known as “mishloach manot.”
"We know through surveys that people are more likely to like Muslims if they know one personally. But because only about 1% of Americans practice the Islamic faith, many people just don’t come into contact with any Muslims."
Purim tells the tale of Esther, an orphaned girl-turned-queen, how she married King Achashverosh, then saved the entire Jewish community in the ancient Persian city of Shushan, through her bravery and wit.
Higher education remains highly unequal and racial divides persist. How can these realities be explained in a context defined by wokeness?
There are so many forces that pull people apart from one another. Institutions and systems and ways of thinking that want us to feel separated, broken, helpless, and quick to capitalize on moments of weakness. The very thing that brings out...
Others noted Rihanna chose to display Ganesh on Feb. 15, the day Hindus celebrate as Ganesh's birthday, or Ganesh Jayanti. The god of beginnings, Ganesh is honored before starting a business or major project.
Until this year, most schools, states and national high school athletic associations had typically forbidden religious headwear, citing safety concerns, unless a student or coach had applied for a waiver. No waiver, no play.
Do a quick Google or YouTube search for tarot, and you’ll find the two main things people tend to inquire about are love and money. Underlying these inquiries is a belief that a tarot reading can tell the future, which begs the question of whether...
The results are based on responses from some 1,800 Black American adults, including more than 800 who attend a Black church. The California research firm conducted the survey in the spring of 2020.
Asian Americans are suffering under the weight of these mounting incidents. Many, including those in our own circles, have expressed concern about leaving their homes to perform everyday tasks.
"Black residents make up a little under half of Washington’s population, but constitute nearly three-fourths of the city's COVID-19 deaths."
Can interfaith leadership foster greater equity for the health of communities of color? Four leaders in healthcare discuss racial health disparities in our nation and how interfaith leadership can be implemented in order to solve them.
“It's an invitation to be subversive by focusing on ourselves."
Across the state, nearly every major health care system has partnered with Black and Hispanic houses of worship to expand vaccine access, setting up mobile clinics in their parking lots and fellowship halls.
Gandhi organized a nonviolent protest on behalf of the farmers. That was when the word satyagraha was used for the first time in the context of a political protest.
Pierce, who is in her 40s and identifies as a Pentecostal, talked with Religion News Service about what she learned from her grandmother, the kinds of hymns she doesn’t sing and her expectations about the future of the Black church.
"We have to develop new approaches to politics that can turn the temperature down on our political conflicts and start bringing people closer together. So much is at stake"
Our nation's very foundation is built on mendacity hermeneutics of scripture and intentional omission of women, indigenous populations, and enslaved Africans from the protection under any of its laws, whether created by Man or divinely inspired.
Ash Wednesday is a time when persons are invited to face their mortality; to remember the limited time we have on this earth and reflect on who we want to be, and the path we want to travel; and who or what we live for.

The opinions contained in this piece are solely the author’s and do not necessarily reflect the views of Interfaith Youth Core. Interfaith America encourages a wide range of views and strives to maintain a respectful tone with a goal of greater understanding and cooperation between people of different faiths, worldviews, and traditions.