The Common Good as Subject and Spirit

Ralph Keen is dean of the UIC Honors College and professor of history and religious studies. The course he describes here was titled “The (Un)Common Good: Social Thought in a Diverse Society,” offered as a first-year course in the Honors College.  

How can an idea that seems to have receded from contemporary thought be brought back to the forefront? By turning it from a concept to an experience. 

A year of isolation for most and dislocation for all was actually the perfect time to develop a new course on the fabric of society and reasons for its fraying in recent years. The extent to which self-interest and in-group identity seem to have eclipsed concern for the neighbor who is not like us is an issue worth asking about, and there can be productive discussion about reasons for the decline of attention to the common good. Productive discussion among two dozen students describes my course last semester from the first week to the last. During a year seemingly suffused with gloom, a course about social unity and fragmentation might be an unlikely high spot. Yet it was the most satisfying course in my teaching career, and student evaluations reflect high satisfaction on their side as well. 

What made it a success? The essential factor was the diversity of the class and their engagement with the questions that ran through the course: are societies by nature closed? Necessarily hierarchical in organization? Who determines the dominant sorting system—race, language, religion—in a given culture, and to what end? Two dozen students, no two of whom to my knowledge shared the same background, brought their perspectives and in some cases brought their families’ stories to bear in bringing these issues to the front of our minds. As first-year students in a general-education course, they did not know each other, and were as different in their preparations and academic interests as they were in backgrounds and cultures. The only thing they had in common was being in the course. 

The composition of the class, together with their willingness to discuss hard questions, contributed in a unique way to the character of the course. For the majority of our authors from Aristotle onward, the population that addressed and maintained the discourse about the common good was coherent and homogenous, whether by political identity, religious culture, or privileged status within a given social organism. The idea of a common good, in other words, was shared among persons with a common identity, persons who formed a “we.” Discussions of the topic take a different form when those conversing have no obvious shared ground apart from being students at our school and in this particular class. Moreover, the power dynamics of social gatekeeping are real and personal for those whose education is their symbolic entry through the gate. 

Over the course of the semester as students got to know each other they began to see that their discussions were a common search for consensus, and came to recognize that the course was an experiment in the subject itself. Wrestling with the authors’ positions, sharing their own sense of the tension between homogenous community and a diverse broader society, debating the concepts of diversity and inclusion: these made every hour an exercise in either coming to agreement or respectful acceptance of different viewpoints. We became, in other words, a community committed to a common good marked by understanding and coexistenceThe subject of the course had become, at the end, our unifying bond. 

During the pandemic the class formed a community only in the virtual sense. The students’ various locations (actual as well as social), with unexpected appearances by others and who knows what sort of background noise for some of them, proved no obstacle to discussion and mutual engagement. They were expected to be every bit as present as if we were all in a classroom, and they were. When they return in the fall they will understand what we mean by community, not just having pondered it as an idea but having, despite obstacles, created one in the process of taking the idea seriously. 


If you are looking for a way to become an interfaith leader, work for racial equity and build bridges, please check out our free curriculum "We Are Each Other's" and start your interfaith leadership today

more from IFYC

Catholics leaders have urged vaccination to "protect the most vulnerable," and studies show this outreach is helping improve vaccination rates among Latino Catholics.
Across the country, people from all political divides, faiths and walks of life are coming together to help resettle Afghan refugees arriving at the borders.
The first episode of “Home Sweet Home,” which DuVernay said prioritizes curiosity over conflict, features the Wixx family — a “super queer” Black couple with three children.
Each week, we share our top 10 religion stories from journals, news sites, podcasts and magazines.
Dr. Abel Gomez: "If we’re talking about interfaith work and we want to expand the ability of communities to practice their religious ceremonies, I ask my students: if we think about the experience of Native people under the occupation of the United States, do they actually have religious freedom?"
The Fisk Jubilee Singers, based at the historically Black university founded by the abolitionist American Missionary Association and later tied to the United Church of Christ, started traveling 150 years ago on Oct. 6, 1871.
The last several months have been catastrophic for Haiti. The Aug. 14 earthquake left more than 2,200 people dead, followed by Tropical Depression Grace two days later. The country’s political sector has been in disarray & over 22,000 people have officially died during the pandemic.
Apache Stronghold will take part in a day of prayer Saturday (Oct. 9) at Oak Flat before meeting with leaders of the Tohono O’odham Nation, who will offer a blessing and prayer for their travels.
It’s not just interactions with friends and families that are getting cut. Routine yet beneficial interactions with people at fitness and child care centers and volunteer organizations are also being eliminated.

The opinions contained in this piece are solely the author’s and do not necessarily reflect the views of Interfaith Youth Core. Interfaith America encourages a wide range of views and strives to maintain a respectful tone with a goal of greater understanding and cooperation between people of different faiths, worldviews, and traditions.