Harvard’s ‘Atheist Chaplain’ Is No Contradiction. It’s A Chance To Grow As A Nation.

(RNS) — The news that humanist chaplain Greg Epstein had been named president of Harvard University’s chaplains was, for many, a moment to celebrate. It was a meaningful inclusion of an underrepresented community, given that atheist, agnostic and nonreligious individuals are often overlooked in religious spaces. Prominent humanist leaders marked it as a time to hold their heads “just a bit higher.”

The news of a nonreligious chaplain in this role at the nation’s iconic academic institution was too much for others, however. Prominent evangelical Tim Keller congratulated Epstein on Twitter, sparking a number of heated replies about why the appointment was not something to celebrate. Babylon Bee, a satirical Christian magazine, offered the punchy headline “Harvard Hires Satan As New Head Chaplain.” The Harvard Christian Alumni Society’s response to Greg’s election was to graciously affirm his leadership, while rejecting the attempt to frame the appointment as a triumph of the secular.

Seeing the elevation of an atheist or agnostic at Harvard as one more skirmish in our nation’s ongoing culture wars misunderstands the significance of this historic moment — and misses an opportunity to live up to the promise of American pluralism.

As a graduate student at Harvard Divinity School, I got to know Greg Epstein through our classes together and, when he became the humanist chaplain, he quickly supported me by hiring me as his first intern as humanist chaplain. Greg’s vision was formative for me as a young adult. He had a name for the values I held — humanism — and beautifully articulated a set of affirmative, positive beliefs, rather than focusing on a disbelief in God.

In a time when the so-called angry atheists seemed to be the standard for unbelief, Greg has been a compelling alternative who stood for community, humanity, common good and working constructively across difference. In every way a modern chaplain does, Greg provided me with powerful faith formation, albeit not a faith in God. Rather, Greg shaped my faith in humanity, my faith in community, my faith in the power of working across lines of difference.

This last virtue is how best to understand Greg’s election, which was led, in part, by an evangelical Christian, alongside a Lutheran, a Christian Scientist and a Baha’i. Why did this group of individuals from diverse identities choose to elevate Greg as a leader? Because they know that Harvard’s campus, like many major universities’ today and indeed our country at large, is a complex of belief and nonbelief, of thriving religious communities and secular groups, often working together, bound by a desire to do good. 

They also know Greg as a leader, and they know he is well-equipped to lead in this pluralistic community. Greg’s track record of collaboration and service to the common good, his commitment to the thriving of religious communities and his listening ear and open heart make him ideal for this role. 

Despite this, we should not dismiss some Christians’ real sense of lament. Many Christian leaders are also devout pluralists, deeply committed to their theological beliefs and deeply committed to an inclusive America. Nevertheless, some perceive Greg’s election as an important loss. One evangelical acquaintance noted that Harvard started as a training ground for religious leaders, only to see religion relegated to the chaplaincy program over time.

“And even now,” this Christian said, “we’re asked, ‘Where’s the space for the nonbelievers?’ The answer is literally anywhere else!”

This is the state of our dialogue about faith in the public square today. Many Christians perceive that their space in culture and society is shrinking, their role ever diminished while the truth of their beliefs remains as salient as ever. Many secular Americans think of themselves as marginalized and underrepresented in a largely religious — make that Christian — nation. 

Painted in these terms, we see only secularists and conservative Christians jockeying for power in a rapidly diversifying landscape, where one community’s success in representation and leadership is another community’s loss.

There are better ways to approach our cultural struggles over belief and values. Rather than assume we’re trapped in a zero-sum game, we can — need to — build our skills for empathy. We can welcome the celebrations of the humanists who finally feel represented, and we can appreciate another step toward inclusion for all.

We can also sit alongside the Christians who lament the implications of this choice, seeking to understand the beliefs that inform this view. We can maintain our own perspectives while respecting the authenticity and sincere motivation of others.

As his friend, I’m celebrating with, and for, Greg, but I’m listening and seeking to understand.

I learned that from Greg. 

If you are looking for a way to become an interfaith leader, work for racial equity and build bridges, please check out our free curriculum "We Are Each Other's" and start your interfaith leadership today

more from IFYC

It is incredibly empowering to know that by protecting yourself, you can protect so many other people.  The Lord gave us the knowledge and people we need in order to defeat COVID-19.
"99.8% of U.S. deaths are of the unvaccinated. If you heard of an airline of that percentage dying, whereas a 0.02% on another, you’re switching flights." -- Dr. Jimmie Smith, Macon-Bibb County Health Department, Georgia.
As a scholar of religious studies, I frequently use critical race theory as a tool to better understand how religion operates in American society.
Inspired by their faith, four LDS students built new study resource that has revolutionized how hundreds of thousands of aspiring physicians study for their exams. "It really started because we just wanted to help people," one said.
We're now in one of the holiest seasons of the year for one of smallest and oldest religions in India -- one with a long history in the United States.
Organizing on-campus vaccination clinics, calling thousands of students, hosting informational webinars with medical experts – these are some of the ways in which IFYC’s Faith in the Vaccine Ambassadors (FIVA) have been raising awareness around the COVID-19 vaccine on campuses and high-need communities across the nation.
Last year's winners, listed below, created a range of initiatives, from virtual retreats and criminal justice initiatives to book clubs and racial equity workshops.
Religious objections, once used sparingly around the country to get exempted from various required vaccines, are becoming a much more widely used loophole against the COVID-19 shot.
What will the campus chapel, and the chaplaincy, look like more than a century from now? Let the adventure begin.
The issue is not the presence of religion in the public square. Instead, the question before us is how to express those religious commitments within in a pluralistic society.
We don’t know what the year 5782 – as it is in the Hebrew calendar – has in store for any of us. But we have the power to act in a way to do right by each other and bring a little more peace and love and joy into this profoundly broken world.
The following interview features Dr. Toby Bressler, senior director of nursing for oncology and clinical quality at the Mount Sinai Health System and vice president of the Orthodox Jewish Nurses Association.
Part of what I found so beautiful about our conversation is that we both agree that American pluralism is not simply a pragmatic solution to the challenge of a diverse democracy, it is also a kind of sacred trust that God intends us to steward.
After 9/11, there was increased intentionality in widening interfaith relations to include a broader number of faith groups and discussions. Twenty years later, it is not unusual to see interreligious conferences, joint advocacy efforts and disaster relief teamwork involving faith groups ranging from Adventists to Zoroastrians.
Twenty years later, we at IFYC, like so many others, collect the shards of memory, recollecting, reconstituting the trauma and horror of that day. And the sacredness is in doing so together.
As we approach this significant anniversary of 9/11, we must work to infuse the day with purpose and pluralism. Pay it Forward 9/11 is bringing people together to do 20,000 good deeds for the 20th anniversary.
In the first month since 9/11, The Sikh Coalition documented over 300 cases of violence and religious discrimination against Sikhs in the U.S. and has since grown to become the largest Sikh advocacy and civil rights organization in the country.
“If you were to quiz these students on what happened on 9/11, they think they knew what happened, but nobody really explained it to them,” Lisa Doi said. “I had to think through, how do you teach this history to somebody who doesn’t really remember it?”
My prayer is that for as long as we remember 9/11, that we will take time to listen to the stories of loss that break our hearts, and join together in finding ways to heal the division, violence and hate that continue to tear apart our world.
It has been 20 years, but the pain of that day is still present in so many places.
20 years after the 9/11 attacks, four remarkable people took profound suffering, loss and grief and “somehow managed to not center enemies. What can we learn from that? How can that be a teaching to the culture?”

The opinions contained in this piece are solely the author’s and do not necessarily reflect the views of Interfaith Youth Core. Interfaith America encourages a wide range of views and strives to maintain a respectful tone with a goal of greater understanding and cooperation between people of different faiths, worldviews, and traditions.