How Shall We Memorialize?

Kadir Nelson creates famed New Yorker image of George Floyd titled Say Their Names, from Twitter

The symmetry of the 1st anniversary of George Floyd’s murder and Memorial Day surfaces two uncomfortable questions. For what have beloved family, friends, and fellow citizens died in America’s wars – what is the character of the nation they sacrificed for, who are we as framed by aspiration?  What does George Floyd’s murder say about the Black experience and what does that, in turn, say about who we are, not by aspiration or national rhetoric, but by particular earthy experience, who are we in light of reality? Further, what is the relationship between aspiration and reality?  

One year later, consider a powerful Sightings piece by Richard Rosengarten, published just after George Floyd’s murder. Rosengarten, University of Chicago Professor of Religion and Literature, juxtaposes two pieces of art, both of which channel the kind of evocatively suggestive social commentary prose falls short of. From the mid-17th Century, Thomas Hobbes ‘frontispiece’ image for his famous inaugural track in social contract theory, Leviathan. From the young 21st Century, painter Nelson Kadir’s June 22, 2020, New Yorker cover, Say Their Names, a memorialization – in the truest sense of the word – of George Floyd.  

Rosengarten’s reflection is characteristically incisive. Hobbes, he reminds us, was painstakingly committed to the frontispiece that would accompany his written opus, commissioning it from a notable artisan of the time, Abraham Bosse. Among his insights is the idea that “Hobbes’s frontispiece represents an idealized sovereignty,” while “Nelson’s drawing represents one distressing and ongoing effect of actualized sovereignty.”

Reflecting one year later, the juxtaposition of Nelson and Hobbes can be deepened. Hobbes’s text is about what we ought to aspire to be, and the socio-political (and ecclesiastical in his case) arrangement that would best foster that aspiration. In his view, the members of the body politic relinquish their sovereignty to the all-powerful leviathan, the only way out of an alternative state of nature that Hobbes famously calls “solitary, nasty, brutish, and short.” Leviathan, and its frontispiece, is an answer to a version of the first question: who we should be as framed by aspiration.

Once a nation’s self-identity is constituted through articulated values and ideals, sentiment within sees the nation worthy of the ultimate sacrifice. That sacrifice is justified in the language of ‘what they died for,’ in American terms freedom, liberty, democracy. Hobbes was not one for freedom, liberty, and democracy, but he begins a lineage in the history of ideas that comes to include democratic understandings of the social contract, like those of Rousseau and Locke. Memorial Day is a cornerstone of our civic religion that ascribes moral excellence to the act of sacrificing one’s life for the American democratic ideal.  

Notably, Leviathan’s frontispiece features anonymous figures, their backs turned away from the viewer as they face the leviathan that they themselves constitute. It is not about who they are individually –they are indistinguishable – the central concern is what they relinquish collectively in entering the social contract, gaining the security that Hobbes believes is only possible through an almighty sovereign.

Leaving aside whether this imagined ideal of the political order is moral or not, the simple point here is that it is a clear statement of an ideal and thus focused on the first question: who should we be? 

Nelson, in contrast, is answering the earthily human second question, who are we in light of reality. Human, ‘of the earth’ and therefore bodied. Specifically, an answer in light of the experiences of Black Americans and the history of racially fueled killings of Black bodies. Floyd’s gaze – to my eye – is ambiguous. But while the bodies of Hobbes’s leviathan are anonymous, not so the majority of those comprising Floyd’s body: they will not fall to anonymity but are memorialized by – where possible – naming. Ahmaud Arbery, Tony McDade, Aiyana Stanley-Jones, Botham Jean, Sandra Bland, Yvette Smith, Breonna Taylor, Eric Garner, Freddie Gray, Laquan McDonald, Trayvon Martin, Alton Sterling, David McAtee, Walter Scott, Tamir Rice, Philando Castille, Stephon Clark, Marin Luther King, Jr., Medgar Evers, Malcolm X, Emmett Till, Rodney King, the Selma Marchers, Rosa Parks, the victims of the Tulsa Race Massacre, Gordon, and finally “The Unnamed” enslaved Black people who remain nameless in unmarked graves.  

And here’s what strikes me the most in Nelson’s painting. So many of their faces are alive, beaming with potential, and expressing something that looks a lot like hope.  Laquan McDonald is painted with a smile on his face in his graduation cap and gown.  Aiyana Stanley-Jones’s braids frame the smirk on her childlike face. Botham Jean, Eric Garner, and Yvette Smith beam.  

Hopeless remembrance too easily leads to embittered resentment. Memorialization does more than remember the past, it sets our eyes on a better future.  Through it, we “re-member” what is possible. We constitute and realize what may be. That is the suggestion in faces Nelson paints into George Floyd.  To move toward that possibility, hope through memorial is essential.  

Finally, in a stroke of brilliance, Nelson laces periwinkle throughout his painting. Periwinkle is the wildflower that was planted at the gravesites holding the remains of nameless enslaved Black people. It has led scholars to those otherwise unmarked sites, in collaboration with organizations like the Periwinkle Initiative. In Say Their Names the periwinkle infuses the color into an achromatic canvas; hopeful color at that. While he faces the question of who we are in light of reality, Nelson doggedly keeps hope within memorialization. Periwinkle is an image to keep in mind this weekend as we lay flowers at the graves of the fallen. Perhaps there is a bridge between who we are in aspiration and who we are in reality.  

If you are looking for a way to become an interfaith leader, work for racial equity and build bridges, please check out our free curriculum "We Are Each Other's" and start your interfaith leadership today

more from IFYC

On Thursday, June 10, 2021, Krista Tippett and Eboo Patel discussed the value of courageous pluralism and deep listening at a pivotal moment of our nation's collective formation. How can we equip young people to best address the needs of our time and beyond—truly cultivating the understanding that we belong to one another?
Interfaith coalitions have long taken up racial justice causes, most famously in the civil rights movements of the '60s, Yet, interfaith organizations themselves have often not taken racial equity work seriously.
The conversation among participants focused on past, present and future possibilities of interfaith collaboration at HBCUs and among Black and African American students on other college campuses.
These women are influencing so many in their community by being beacons of the values they hold dear, and that is an incredible way to guide a community. 
While pursuing a master’s degree in Buddhist studies, Han decided to focus her thesis on documenting the nuances of Asian American Buddhists, a community that seemed almost nonexistent, she wrote.
He sees potential for future science-informed partnerships between the government and faith communities to tackle the pandemic.
What has happened in our institution provides a template for similar institutions who may be going through some challenges in establishing an interfaith program. It shows that being true to one’s faith and being inclusive are not opposites.
I hear my sisters and brothers calling out in cacophony, “Aint I a Human?” When Sojourner Truth considered the ways in which white women were revered and protected; when she witnessed the ways their gentility and femininity were affirmed and nurtured; when she experienced the contrast in how she was treated relative to those who shared her gender but not her color, she was compelled to ask, “Aint I a Woman?”
The following interview features Imam Makram El-Amin, who has led the Masjid An-Nur (Mosque of Light) in Minneapolis for 25 years and serves as executive director of Al-Maa’uun, the mosque’s community outreach organization.
The following interview features Anthony Cruz Pantojas, co-chair of the Latinx Humanist Alliance, an affiliate of the American Humanist Association.
The following interview features Micah Fries, director of programs at the Multi-Faith Neighbors Network and director of engagement at GlocalNet.
The church first started offering vaccine doses in January in an effort to boost the vaccination rates in New York City’s Black and Hispanic communities.
This article is part of a series called Faith in the Field that explores responses to Covid-19—including vaccination efforts—within different faith communities. 
Fr. Dennis Holtschneider, president of the Association of Catholic Colleges and Universities, talks about the Catholic response to the pandemic.
Fred Davie joins Alia Bilal, Anthea Butler, Adam Russell Taylor and Eric Lewis Williams in a conversation that gets to the heart of how interfaith cooperation can be a part of accountability, justice, and reconciliation in America’s next chapter.
Two thousand volunteers of diverse faiths will engage people through their religious communities.
"Over the years, people have asked if I was 'called' to be a rabbi, and the truth is I don't know, but what I do know is I did listen to an inner voice which I now believe was a holy voice. That holy voice led me to listen even when I doubted..."
The USS Olympia is home to the Difficult Journey Home exhibit that opens May 28, and a historical marker will be unveiled during the Museum’s Memorial Day ceremony on Monday, May 31. Independence Seaport Museum
Six congregations gathered to mark the centennial of the massacre and to honor the persistence of the Black church tradition in Greenwood.
This past year’s pandemic and social isolation only made this worse. Consequently, hate crimes and systemic racism were more prevalent than ever.
Perhaps there is a bridge between who we are in aspiration and who we are in reality?

The opinions contained in this piece are solely the author’s and do not necessarily reflect the views of Interfaith Youth Core. Interfaith America encourages a wide range of views and strives to maintain a respectful tone with a goal of greater understanding and cooperation between people of different faiths, worldviews, and traditions.